Notes:
This church was constructed in 1876-77, and replaced an earlier log church that was once known as Twaddle's Chapel. In 1883, when the Primitive Methodists united with Wesleyans, the members of this church refused to join with the Wesleyans at Victoria Park Avenue, and instead united with St. Andrew's in Bendale, becoming known at that time as the Zion Presbyterian Church. In 1925, the congregation became a part of the United Church of Canada.
In 1955, a new church was built that attaches to the older one.